Before You Pitch It...

Whether you are moving, downsizing, or just doing some spring cleaning—you may want to take a closer look at your items before pitching them. These unassuming household items can be hiding in plain sight and the value they hold may surprise you. Before you make a trip to the dump or donation center take time to do some research so you can turn your trash into treasure.

Antique Tools
“They sure don’t make them like they used to..”, the old adage rings true when it comes to collecting vintage and antique tools. Well maintained antique tools can last decades and even be of better quality than their modern-day counterparts. Apart from being solidly built, antique tools are beautifully crafted and often used for decorative display purposes as well. Even if your old tools are no longer the shiniest in the shed they are worth taking a closer look at.
Fishing Equipment
Vintage and antique fishing equipment has become highly collectible by hobbyists and industry professionals. Many older fishing lures are handmade and hand-painted and carry an Americana/Folk Art aesthetic which makes them even more desirable to a larger audience. Collectors are interested in early lures constructed of wood—but reels, rods, and decoys are also highly sought after.

EBTH Cincinnati - Blue Ash
Eucalyptus Outdoor Bench with Green Striped Cushion

EBTH Cincinnati - Blue Ash
Hermès Cashmere and Silk Blend Sleeveless Top in Persimmon

EBTH Cincinnati - Blue Ash
Signed "Blue Dog" by George Rodrigue and Lawrence S. Freundlich, 1994

EBTH Cincinnati - Blue Ash
Miu Miu Top Handle Bag in Yellow Leather
Vintage Computers
In today’s world it seems computers become quickly obsolete, only to be replaced by a newer and better model. However old tech dinosaurs are coming back around in the collecting world and demanding big prices. Dated technology from the dawn of the tech boom (70s, 80s, and 90s) is catching the attention of collectors interested in technology. Vintage computers hold a great deal of nostalgia, but are also sought after for the historical value and rarity they have. Computers, processors, and even accessories may be worth a quick google search to see if you have a diamond in the rough.
Perfume Bottles
Crafted out of glass to exude luxury and sensuality, perfume bottles are beautiful objects in their own right. Bottles were originally produced by hand in small batches, but were later replaced by large production runs after the Industrial Revolution. Perfume bottles can be found in a variety of shapes and sizes, everything from large vessels to smaller ones meant to work as necklaces. Antique hand-made examples with ornate designs, or high-end designer brands are highly sought after in the collecting world.


EBTH Cincinnati - Blue Ash
Pair of Renaissance Style Upholstered Armchairs with Accent Pillows

EBTH Columbus - Hilliard
World Market Upholstered Club Chair, 2019

EBTH Cincinnati - Blue Ash
Flint & Horner Co. Georgian Style Flame Mahogany Sideboard, 20th Century

EBTH Cincinnati - Blue Ash
Burberry Haymarket Check Canvas Mini Tote with Brown Saffiano Leather Trim

Vintage Toys & Games
Parents often want to purge what they have held onto over years after their kids finally leave the nest. Things like vintage toys, video games, and cards are often among the first to go in an attempt to declutter the house. However these items can hold significant value and are making a name for themselves amongst collectors seeking a wave of nostalgia. In today’s market the right Pokémon card can be worth hundreds of thousands of dollars, so before you pitch it make sure you don’t have something special.
Vintage Clothing
Vintage clothing is having its moment amongst younger generations who have traded in the fast fashion culture for unique quality apparel. Everything from early Victorian handmade garments to 2000s Y2K mass produced clothing is sought after amongst collectors. Vintage pieces offer quality and style for people wanting to set themselves apart from the trends and help reduce the almost 80% of textiles that end up in landfills.

EBTH Cincinnati - Blue Ash
Jason Michael Durham Abstract Mixed Media Painting "Wildflowers," 2025

EBTH Cincinnati - Blue Ash
Deborah Kovacs-Sturdevant Mixed Media Composition "Siren of the Sea"

EBTH Columbus - Hilliard
Kroehler Modernist Upholstered Sofa with Nailhead Trim

EBTH Cincinnati - Blue Ash
Dorothy Kizer Bucolic Landscape Oil Painting
Kitchenware
Old, dirty, and outdated kitchen items may be an obvious thing to want to pitch into the trash, but some items can actually be quite collectible. Brands like Pyrex, Corningware, and Dansk are all in high demand given their quality and unique design styles. Antique pieces and kitchenware from the 50’s including glassware, cookware, utensils, and decor in fun prints are the most desired. Cast iron in particular may appear to be old and rusted but after some cleaning and reasoning could be worth hundreds of dollars.
Vintage Holiday Decor
Vintage holiday decor is widely collectible and brings back a sense of tradition and nostalgia that we associate with certain holidays. Vintage colorful and kitschy decor can be endearing and a great way to add some uniqueness to your favorite holidays. Decorations like antique Christmas ornaments and spooky halloween decorations offer unique designs that can’t be found anywhere else. Halloween decorations, often made of paper, were meant to be thrown away after the holiday making them even more rare and desirable.


EBTH Cincinnati - Blue Ash
Portrait Oil Painting of Young Woman In Fine Dress, 19th Century

EBTH Columbus - Hilliard
Chinese Style Pine Platform Armchairs, Pair, Mid to Late 20th Century

EBTH Cincinnati - Blue Ash
Zadro Towel Warmer

EBTH Cincinnati - Blue Ash
First UK Adult Edition "Harry Potter and the Order of the Phoenix" by Rowling

EBTH Cincinnati - Blue Ash
Sterling Pearl and Emerald Drop Earrings

EBTH Cincinnati - Blue Ash
Vintage 10K Rose Gold Flower Drop Pendant

EBTH Cincinnati - Blue Ash
Natalia Demenko Still Life Oil Painting of Heinz Mustard, 21st Century

EBTH Cincinnati - Blue Ash